The first ten films (plus alternatives) that I posted yesterday were in response to a request from someone in the parish I go to to recommend ten must see films for Catholics. Occasional film showings there have usually been
successful. But for those of you following my recommendations, why stop at the first ten. Here's the next ten in importance.
1. The Decalogue directed by
Krzysztof Kieslowski. This is actually a set of 10 films originally made for Polish television. Each of the films is under an hour.
Kiewslowski is influenced by
existentialism and the polish situation as much as he is by
Christianity in these films. They were made shortly before the fall of communism, but he didn't seen to be censored significantly, although he had great difficulty getting permission for the filming. The films take place, each to varying extents, in and around a very large housing project so that they have there "coincidence" some overlapping characters. Film V, about a brutal murder of a taxi driver and the equally brutal application of the death penalty is the most
accessible of the films, so I recommend you start there.
See
http://www.filmref.com/directors/dirpages/kieslowski.html and also
http://www.lumiere.net.nz/reader/content/features/decalogue_the_1.html for more information.
2. Luther directed by Eric Till, starting Joseph
Fiennes. Why should a Catholic see a film about the man who split the church in the west? For understanding, so that
dialogue could ensue. This films shows Luther as
passionate and intense and shows his falls and regrets an his accomplishments. While it has some falls in
historical emphasis, it
doesn't show the Catholic Church as all wrong or Luther as all right. If I were making a list of greatest films, I would not recommend this one, but given the
subject, I recommend it.
3. The Passion of Joan of Arc, directed by Carl
Dreyer. Silent, black and white. The complete edition was a lost film, destroyed in a fire like Joan. Finally a copy with the directors cut was found in broom closet in an insane asylum. Dryers account
minimizes the unnecessary details and focuses on the trial and execution, based on the actual trial transcript. Renee
Faconetti, in her only screen
performance,
portrayed Joan better than anyone before or since. The film jars us with close ups, odd angles, sweeping movements, intense facial expressions and deliberately odd editing. One of the greatest of the silent films.
4. The Mission , directed by Roland
Joffe, starting Robert De
Niro and Jeremy Irons. The Mission , winner of the 1986 Cannes Film Festival Best Picture Award, including best picture shows the brutal colonial
subjugation of South American Indians, and the Jesuit opposition to their treatment. It deals with
penance, service, violence and non-violence. It's visually a stunning movie.
5. The Quarrel , directed by Eli Cohen. Now I'm recommending Jewish
movies for a Catholic film study. This is a wonderful film about a chance reunion of two
Holocaust survivors in 1948. While it deals with a question in the Jewish community, I see
parallels in the Christian community. One character has become a deeply religious rabbi, and the other a novelist and journalist who, once religious, has turned his back on God. In there disputation they examine good and evil, faith, redemption and friendship.
6. The Passion of Joshua the Jew, directed by Pasquale
Scimeca. a
brillant film dealing with relations between Jews, Muslims and Christians. The action starts in 1492 Spain and moves to Italy. It traces the journey of a young scholar an important rabbi thinks is the Messiah. Drawing from the
Qur'an, the Torah, the Gospels and historical
circumstance it
portrays his parallel fate to Jesus of Nazareth.
See
http://www.italianfilmfestival.co.nz/films/2006/film11.htm for more information.
7. Therese by Alain Cavalier.
French with English subtitles. Winner of the 1986 Cannes Film Festival Jury Award. This is a wonderful and focused examination of St. Therese Martin, the Little Flower, who at 15 became a
Carmelite nun by special intervention of the Pope. She was called the greatest saint of modern times by Pope
Puis XI. Unlike the more recent American film of the same title, this film
doesn't deal much with what proceeds Therese's vocation, and focuses on fewer incidents in her life. It therefor
portrays her with a greater intensity, more focused on the
essentials. It meditates on these essentials.
See
http://www.spiritualityandpractice.com/films/films.php?id=5046 for more information.
8. The Message, directed by
Moustapha Akkad. Yes, this is the film about Mohammad starting Anthony Quinn. Every Catholic should be well informed not only on their own faith, but about Islam,
Judaism and Protestantism. This is the best film ever made about the birth of Islam and whatever one thinks of Islam, one cannot avoid it. As always with Quinn, well acted,
9. The Ninth Day, directed by
Volker Schlondorff. German in English subtitles. There are a lot of excellent films as alternatives to this dealing with the question of the Holocaust, like Schindler's List. A Catholic film study should review at least one of them, dealing with one of the greatest moral challenges of our times. But this particular
film deals with the true story of a Catholic priest,
furloughed from Dachau. Fr Henri
Kremer was in the priest block in the infamous concentration camp, clinging to life and struggling with faith. He was released and asked to persuade his anti-Nazi Bishop to surrender to Nazi occupation. He is told that to fail means his death and his families death, and is given nine days.
10. Entertaining Angels, the Dorothy Day Story, directed by Michael Ray Rhodes. Again here is a picture I wouldn't put in my 100 greatest films of all time, but it
survives a useful purpose. Ever Catholic film study should examine what the church does about social justice and this film does that very well. It
portrays the life of
Dorothy Day, a co-founder of the Catholic Worker Movement. In her unbending concern for the poor, she has often been called the "American Mother
Teressa."
There are more great films a
Catholic should see, and my two lists are
insufficient. The Vatican, several years ago, created a recommended film list which overlaps some with mine. Here is the link:
http://www.spiritualityandpractice.com/films/films.php?id=5046